Best 1-2-3 Punch
What album has the best 1-2-3 Punch?
That is, what album has the most impressive arrangement of Tracks 1, 2, and 3–an arrangement that hooks the listener and predisposes them to register rave reviews (even if Tracks 4 and on are disposable) ?
Within these first 3 songs, the musicians attempt to declare the album as worthy of your time. Those who don’t like what they find in these 3 tracks will not likely give the rest of the release a fair listen.
So, that leaves the question: what is a 1-2-3 Punch formula that works?
It is not just a matter of stacking 3 high-quality songs at the beginning and calling it good. 3 fast and catchy songs in a row might cancel each other out or exhaust the listener rather quickly. Similarly, 3 long, slow-building epics in a row would be an album-crushing mistake. As with any movie, the flow becomes very important to maximize enjoyment.
My favorite 1-2-3 Punch can be found on Broken Social Scene’s You Forget it in People and I believe that it employs the most sure-fire formula, as described below.
ONE FORMULA THAT WORKS:
Track 1 – “The Tension Builder” – This track builds some tension and sets the mood. It is slower and more ambient. It may be instrumental or may include vocals, but it does not have a traditional verse-chorus structure.
Track 2 – “The Explosion” – This track explodes forward like a race horse out of the gates and shows the musicians at their boldest and most expressive. It has a faster tempo and provides the ‘release’ following Track 1’s build.
Track 3 – “We Got This” – A mid-tempo, memorable piece that shows the musicians in masterful song-crafting form. It is their chance to proclaim: “We got this… We know what we’re doing.” The verse-chorus structure may help here but is not required. This song may function, either formally or informally, as the album’s single.
To hear this 1-2-3 Punch in action, go ahead and stream You Forget it in People here.
Filed under: tk | 4 Comments
Tags: broken social scene, kool aid
2000s 2010 afi alkaline trio animal collective annuals antlers antony and the johnsons arcade fire band of horses beck blink 182 bob dylan bon iver broken social scene coheed and cambria coldplay cut copy daft punk death cab for cutie decemberists dirty projectors dr. dog five iron frenzy fleet foxes foo fighters fun girls girl talk hives jack's mannequin jack white janelle monae jimmy eat world joanna newsom jonsi kanye west kid cudi killers knife local natives m83 matisyahu metric michael jackson modest mouse muse national of montreal panda bear panic! at the disco pantha du prince passion pit phoenix radiohead rocket summer she & him shins shout out louds sigur ros spoon strokes sufjan stevens taking back sunday tallest man on earth this blog tv on the radio u.s.e. vampire weekend vedera war on drugs weezer white stripes xx yeasayer